AGENT SKILL

research-contradictions

暂无简介

License 许可
MIT
最近更新
2026-06-13
Stars
★ 3
Forks
1

01 前言 Front Matter

id
research-contradictions
title
Contradiction Resolution

03 SKILL.md 正文

Contradiction Resolution

Systematically identify and resolve conflicting evidence using a structured taxonomy of resolution strategies.

Detection

Scan evidence-grades.json for:

  • Claims that directly oppose each other
  • Claims with conflicting effect directions for the same outcome
  • Hypotheses with mixed support (some evidence supporting, some refuting)

Resolution Strategies (apply in order)

1. Weight of Evidence

Compare GRADE ratings and effect sizes between conflicting claims. If one side has substantially stronger evidence (higher grade AND larger effect), adopt it. Document the evidence asymmetry.

2. Scope Refinement

Both claims may be valid under different conditions. Restate with narrower scope. Example: "X causes Y" vs "X doesn't cause Y" becomes "X causes Y under condition Z but not under condition W".

3. Methodological Reconciliation

Different methodologies may explain the conflict. Document:

  • What methods each side used
  • Which methodology is more appropriate for the question
  • Whether methodological differences fully explain the discrepancy

4. Unresolved

If no strategy resolves the conflict, flag it with:

  • Specific questions for the next epoch's literature search
  • Suggested methodology to resolve it
  • Impact assessment (how much does this affect the overall conclusion?)

Quality Criteria

  • All contradictions are identified (no silent conflicts)
  • Resolution strategy is documented for each
  • Unresolved contradictions have specific next-step questions
  • Confidence in each resolution is rated

04 同仓库更多 Skills

openplaybooks-dev
openplaybooks-dev/converge

hello-checker

Use this skill when asked to "verify", "check", or "validate" a file's existence and content. It provides a reliable workflow for confirming files meet their spec.

Skill与智能体开发
★ 3
openplaybooks-dev
openplaybooks-dev/converge

ask-skill

暂无简介

Skill与智能体开发
★ 3
openplaybooks-dev
openplaybooks-dev/converge

html-review-artifact

Framework-wide guidance for crafting polished human-review artifacts as markdown or HTML

前端开发Skill与智能体开发
★ 3
openplaybooks-dev
openplaybooks-dev/converge

converge-planning

Design a Converge playbook end-to-end. Use when the user says "plan a project", "design a playbook", "decompose into tasks", "scaffold a Converge workflow", "onboard to Converge", or asks how to write TASK.md / playbook.yml. Two entry points: plan a new playbook or update an existing one. Hand off to `/converge-control` after producing the playbook structure.

Skill与智能体开发
★ 3
openplaybooks-dev
openplaybooks-dev/converge

converge-control

Operate a Converge playbook end-to-end — start runs, monitor progress, narrow failures with `--select`, inspect runtime state, validate definitions, surgically reset subtrees, and stop stuck or orphaned runs. Use this skill whenever the user says "run my playbook", "execute this", "monitor the run", "converge failed", "the run is stuck", "retry failures", "babysit this playbook", "what's the status?", "show me the gantt", or asks how to use `converge run` / `--select` / `inspect` / `doctor` / `clean` / `stop`. Also use it for `HTTP 401` / `Invalid API key` failures on the first task — those are environment-not-playbook problems — and for any post-run cleanup work. Hand off to `converge-planning` if the user wants to design or restructure the playbook itself.

开发工程师Skill与智能体开发
★ 3
openplaybooks-dev
openplaybooks-dev/converge

repair-taskts

Fix task.ts definition issues — Seed syntax, missing .build(), empty checks, import errors, TypeScript errors

开发工程师
★ 3