AGENT SKILL

scientific-thinking-scholar-evaluation

Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers, proposals, literature reviews, methods sections, evidence quality, citation support, and research-writing feedback. Use when evaluating academic or scientific work — papers, proposals, methods sections, or evidence quality — against a repeatable rubric.

License 许可
MIT
最近更新
2026-11-11
Stars
★ 3
Forks
0

01 前言 Front Matter

name
scientific-thinking-scholar-evaluation
metadata
{ "origin": "community" }
description
Structured scholarly-work evaluation for papers, proposals, literature reviews, methods sections, evidence quality, citation support, and research-writing feedback. Use when evaluating academic or scientific work — papers, proposals, methods sections, or evidence quality — against a repeatable rubric.

03 SKILL.md 正文

Scholar Evaluation

Use this skill to evaluate academic or scientific work with a repeatable rubric.

When to Use

  • Reviewing a research paper, proposal, thesis chapter, or literature review.
  • Checking whether claims are supported by cited evidence.
  • Evaluating methodology, study design, analysis, or limitations.
  • Comparing two or more papers for quality or relevance.
  • Producing structured feedback for revision.

Evaluation Scope

Start by identifying the artifact:

  • empirical research paper
  • theoretical paper
  • technical report
  • systematic or narrative literature review
  • research proposal
  • thesis or dissertation chapter
  • conference abstract or short paper

Then choose scope:

  • comprehensive: all rubric dimensions
  • targeted: one or two dimensions, such as method or citations
  • comparative: rank multiple works against the same rubric

Rubric

Score each applicable dimension from 1 to 5:

  • 5: excellent; clear, rigorous, and publication-ready
  • 4: good; minor improvements needed
  • 3: adequate; meaningful gaps but usable
  • 2: weak; substantial revision needed
  • 1: poor; major validity or clarity problems

Use N/A for dimensions that do not apply.

1. Problem and Research Question

  • Is the problem clear and specific?
  • Is the contribution meaningful?
  • Are scope and assumptions explicit?
  • Does the question match the claimed contribution?

2. Literature and Context

  • Is relevant prior work covered?
  • Does the work synthesize rather than merely list sources?
  • Are gaps accurately identified?
  • Are recent and foundational sources balanced?

3. Methodology

  • Does the method answer the research question?
  • Are design choices justified?
  • Are variables, datasets, participants, or materials described clearly?
  • Could another researcher reproduce the work?
  • Are ethical and practical constraints acknowledged?

4. Data and Evidence

  • Are data sources credible and appropriate?
  • Is sample size or corpus coverage adequate?
  • Are inclusion, exclusion, and preprocessing decisions documented?
  • Are missing data and bias risks discussed?

5. Analysis

  • Are statistical, qualitative, or computational methods appropriate?
  • Are baselines and controls fair?
  • Are uncertainty, sensitivity, or robustness checks included when needed?
  • Are alternative explanations considered?

6. Results and Interpretation

  • Are results clearly presented?
  • Do claims stay within the evidence?
  • Are figures, tables, and metrics understandable?
  • Are negative or null results handled honestly?

7. Limitations and Threats to Validity

  • Are limitations specific rather than generic?
  • Are internal, external, construct, and conclusion-validity risks addressed?
  • Does the paper distinguish speculation from demonstrated results?

8. Writing and Structure

  • Is the argument easy to follow?
  • Are sections organized around the research question?
  • Are definitions and notation clear?
  • Is the tone precise and scholarly?

9. Citations

  • Do cited papers support the claims attached to them?
  • Are primary sources used where possible?
  • Are reviews labeled as reviews?
  • Are preprints labeled as preprints?
  • Are citation metadata and links correct?

Review Process

  1. Read the abstract, introduction, figures, and conclusion for claimed contribution.
  2. Read methods and results for evidence quality.
  3. Check the strongest claims against cited sources.
  4. Score each applicable dimension.
  5. Separate critical blockers from revision suggestions.
  6. End with concrete next edits.

Output Template

# Scholar Evaluation: <Artifact>

## Overall Assessment

- Overall score: <1-5 or N/A>
- Confidence: <high | medium | low>
- Summary: <3-5 sentences>

## Dimension Scores

| Dimension | Score | Evidence | Revision priority |
| --- | ---: | --- | --- |
| Problem and question |  |  |  |
| Literature and context |  |  |  |
| Methodology |  |  |  |
| Data and evidence |  |  |  |
| Analysis |  |  |  |
| Results and interpretation |  |  |  |
| Limitations |  |  |  |
| Writing and structure |  |  |  |
| Citations |  |  |  |

## Critical Issues

## Recommended Revisions

## Evidence Checks Needed

Pitfalls

  • Do not use the score as a substitute for concrete feedback.
  • Do not penalize a paper for omitting a dimension outside its scope.
  • Do not treat citation count, venue, or author reputation as proof of quality.
  • Do not accept unsupported claims just because they appear in the abstract.

04 同仓库更多 Skills

mdnaimul22
mdnaimul22/human-skills

system-lifecycle-designer

Universal architectural methodology for designing granular, atomic, and sub-atomic lifecycles and end-to-end workflows for single functionality integrations across any domain (daemons, batch jobs, request transactions, resource pools). Provides patterns for deterministic identity, pre-commit validation, differential reconciliation, sticky leasing, state machines, transactional persistence, and closed-loop feedback.

★ 3
mdnaimul22
mdnaimul22/human-skills

style-sampling

Make a new episode in a proven video style - Collage Explainer, Finance Explainer, Animated Science Explainer, 3D Brand Explainer, 3D True Crime - on the person's topic. Use for "an episode of", "in the style of", "sample this style", 「用这个风格做一集」. One video to copy is reverse-any-video.

★ 3
mdnaimul22
mdnaimul22/human-skills

reverse-any-video

Rebuild any video file as an editable HyperFrames project - motion graphics, talking heads, live action or AI-generated footage - checked against the original frame by frame. Use to reverse, recreate, remake, replicate or copy a video, or 「复刻这个视频」「照着这个视频做一个」.

★ 3
mdnaimul22
mdnaimul22/human-skills

typescript-patterns

TypeScript patterns for strict, type-safe, maintainable code in modern TypeScript and JavaScript applications. Covers strict compiler configuration, type design, narrowing, discriminated unions, generics, async and error handling, module boundaries, dependency hygiene, and type-level testing. Use when writing or reviewing TypeScript or JavaScript code.

★ 3
mdnaimul22
mdnaimul22/human-skills

test-collaboration

Inventory and govern a project's test assets. Connect requirements, business rules, risks, bugs, and cross-boundary contracts to stable TEST-IDs and executable evidence in the repository's existing test registry or TESTS.md. Use for test inventory, test gap analysis, unit/integration/contract/E2E/smoke classification, bug-to-test regression protection, consumer/provider contract testing, test-necessity review, and pre-delivery evidence review.

★ 3
mdnaimul22
mdnaimul22/human-skills

story-lifecycle

Manage a file-based epic → story → sprint development loop without requiring an external project management tool. Creates and tracks epics, breaks them into user stories, assigns them to sprints, and drives implementation story by story. Use when starting a new feature initiative or when the team has no Jira/Linear/Taiga but needs structured delivery tracking.

★ 3