AGENT SKILL

rebuttal-and-response-to-reviewers

Plan and write responses to peer review, including journal "response to reviewers" letters for revise-and-resubmit, conference rebuttals under strict length limits (OpenReview/ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML, ACL ARR, CVPR), author responses to meta-reviews, and appeals. Use when a user receives reviews, must triage reviewer comments, draft point-by-point replies, decide what new experiments to run, disagree respectfully with a reviewer, or track manuscript changes for a revision. For authors answering reviews of their own manuscript; to write a review of someone else's paper, use peer-review instead.

License 许可
MIT
最近更新
2026-11-08
Stars
★ 0
Forks
0

01 前言 Front Matter

name
rebuttal-and-response-to-reviewers
license
MIT
metadata
{ "tags": "peer review, rebuttal, response to reviewers, revise and resubmit, OpenReview, author response", "author": "Kalaris Labs (Sayan Chowdhury)", "version": "1.0", "category": "research-writing", "maintainer": "Kalaris Labs" }
description
Plan and write responses to peer review, including journal "response to reviewers" letters for revise-and-resubmit, conference rebuttals under strict length limits (OpenReview/ICLR, NeurIPS, ICML, ACL ARR, CVPR), author responses to meta-reviews, and appeals. Use when a user receives reviews, must triage reviewer comments, draft point-by-point replies, decide what new experiments to run, disagree respectfully with a reviewer, or track manuscript changes for a revision. For authors answering reviews of their own manuscript; to write a review of someone else's paper, use peer-review instead.
compatibility
No runtime dependencies.

03 SKILL.md 正文

Responding to Reviewers

The audience of a response is the editor or area chair, who must decide quickly whether concerns were addressed. Make every reply easy to verify: quote the concern, answer it directly, show the change with a location.

Step 1: Triage (before writing anything)

Split every review into atomic comments and classify each in a table:

ID Reviewer Comment (short) Type Effort Plan
R1.1 1 Missing baseline X Experiment High Run X on 2 datasets
R2.3 2 Claim in §4 overstated Wording Low Soften + add limitation

Types: misunderstanding (the text was unclear), missing analysis/experiment, wording/presentation, disagreement on substance, out of scope, factual error by reviewer.

Then:

  • Identify the 2-3 concerns that drive the scores (often shared across reviewers). These get the most effort and appear first in a conference rebuttal.
  • Decide what is feasible in the revision window. Never promise experiments you will not run.
  • Note conflicts between reviewers so the editor can adjudicate.

Step 2: Do the work, then write

Run the experiments and edit the manuscript before drafting replies, so every reply can point to a concrete change. Keep a change log with section/page/line numbers.

Step 3: Reply patterns

Journal response letter (no strict length):

Reviewer 1, Comment 1: "<quote or faithful summary of the concern>"

Response: We thank the reviewer for ... [direct answer in the first sentence].
We have [action]. The new results (Table 3, p. 7, lines 210-224) show ...

Change in manuscript: "<quoted new/revised text>" (Section 4.2, p. 7)

Best practices:

  • Answer in the first sentence ("Yes, we have added...", "We agree and have...", "We respectfully disagree because...").
  • Thanks once per reviewer, not before every comment.
  • Quote revised text so the reviewer need not hunt for it. Provide a tracked-changes/diff version if the journal allows.
  • Number comments (R1.1, R1.2 ...) and cross-reference instead of repeating ("see our response to R2.1").

Disagreeing (it is allowed and expected when justified):

  1. Acknowledge the underlying concern ("We understand the concern that ...").
  2. Give evidence: data, citations, a small additional analysis, or a precise explanation.
  3. Make a concession where honest: a clarification in the text or a stated limitation. Never be sarcastic, never say the reviewer "failed to understand". Rewrite the text so the next reader won't.

Conference rebuttal (hard limits: characters/words per reviewer or one page; check the venue):

  • Lead with a short general response covering shared concerns and new results.
  • Then per reviewer, only the comments that affect the decision, 2-5 sentences each.
  • Put new numbers in compact tables. State exactly what will change in the camera-ready.
  • Correct factual misreadings politely with pointers ("Section 3.2, Eq. 4 defines ...").
  • Respect the venue's rules on new experiments, links and supplementary material. Many prohibit external links or new PDFs during rebuttal.
  • On OpenReview discussions: reply promptly and concisely, and summarize the resolved points for the AC near the end.

Step 4: Cover note to the editor (journals)

Summarize the main changes in 3-6 bullets, flag any reviewer disagreements you could not resolve and why, and confirm all co-authors approved the revision.

Quality checklist

  • Every comment has a response. Count them against the triage table.
  • Every "we have added/changed" is actually in the manuscript at the cited location.
  • New numbers match between response, manuscript, tables and abstract.
  • Tone: professional, specific, never defensive. Read it as the reviewer would.
  • No new claims beyond what the revised evidence supports.
  • Length within the venue limit (count it).

Related skills

peer-review (reviewing others' work: useful to anticipate criticism), scientific-writing, ml-paper-writing, scientific-critical-thinking, statistical-analysis.

04 同仓库更多 Skills

Tashima-Tarsh
Tashima-Tarsh/Disha6.6

youtube-full

Use when the user needs YouTube transcripts, video search, channel browsing, playlist extraction, or content monitoring. Trigger phrases: 'get the transcript for', 'search YouTube for', 'what are the latest videos on', 'list this playlist', 'monitor this channel', or any request involving a YouTube URL, video ID, or @handle. Do NOT use for downloading video or audio files, YouTube engagement data (likes, comments), or private/age-restricted videos.

图像与多媒体
★ 0
Tashima-Tarsh
Tashima-Tarsh/Disha6.6

x-twitter-growth

X/Twitter growth engine for building audience, crafting viral content, and analyzing engagement. Use when the user wants to grow on X/Twitter, write tweets or threads, analyze their X profile, research competitors on X, plan a posting strategy, or optimize engagement. Complements social-content (generic multi-platform) with X-specific depth: algorithm mechanics, thread engineering, reply strategy, profile optimization, and competitive intelligence via web search.

★ 0
Tashima-Tarsh
Tashima-Tarsh/Disha6.6

write-a-skill

Create new agent skills with proper structure, progressive disclosure, and bundled resources. Use when user wants to create, write, build, or author a new skill.

Skill与智能体开发
★ 0
Tashima-Tarsh
Tashima-Tarsh/Disha6.6

wrap-up

Close out a launched Claude Managed Agent — recap every primitive the founder now owns, regenerate the single-file overview page, and suggest the next 1-2 upgrades. Use when the user says "wrap up", "close this out", "what do I own now", "give me the summary", "recap the agent", or when the orchestrator routes phase=wrap-up. primitives_inventory.py tables everything owned (agent, environment, session, memory, outcome, deployment); overview_page.py regenerates a self-contained ./my-agent/agent-overview.html; upgrade_suggester.py ranks the next moves from recorded deferrals plus standing hardening steps. Companion to run-without-you; the last stop before phase=done.

★ 0
Tashima-Tarsh
Tashima-Tarsh/Disha6.6

workflow-builder

Design and write deterministic multi-agent workflow scripts (.js files in .claude/workflows/) for Claude Code's Workflow tool. Use when a user wants to build, create, author, scaffold, or run a custom Claude Code workflow, orchestrate sub-agents (fan-out, pipeline, loop, judge-panel), or automate a repeatable multi-step task across fresh-context agents.

Skill与智能体开发
★ 0
Tashima-Tarsh
Tashima-Tarsh/Disha6.6

weekly-review

Use when someone wants to run a weekly review, close open loops, audit stalled projects and commitments, get their system back to trusted, restart a lapsed review habit, or says "/cs:weekly-review". Walks David Allen's three-phase loop — GET CLEAR, GET CURRENT, GET CREATIVE — with deterministic scripts that inventory open loops, gate the checklist with named gaps, and score commitment health 0-100.

★ 0